For my son's 11-12 All Star team the Mom's made these stars for them. We hung them on the dugout at every game. I really loved the way these turned out. The large gold star is an 18" cardboard cut from Party City. The black sparkly paper I bought at Target...love this! The other papers are Recollections Precious Metals.
I did find that the usual scrapbook adhesives did not work very well when trying to adhere the cuts to the glitter paper. I ended up going back over them with good old Elmer's glue. Enjoy!